All posts by Cliff Barnes

Is former Cowboy Aikman unbiased when announcing Redskins games?

For some unknown reason, Fox Sports has had former Dallas Cowboy quarterback Troy Aikman doing color commentary on Washington Redskins games this year… and Redskins fans aren’t happy about it.

In Sunday’s 17-14 victory over the Bears, Aikman several times lobbied for calls that would help Chicago. For instance, he kept saying that DeAngelo Hall should have been penalized for excessive celebration for going down to both knees after a 92-yard interception return for a TD (which ultimately was the game winner). See the accompanying photo.

A guy makes a one-handed catch and runs 92 yards with it for a score and he wants to talk about his going to his knees. With all the jerk celebrations that go on around the league, he says it would have been ok had he gone down on one knee but not two. “Going to two knees there, I think that should have been a flag,” he said.

A couple of years ago, Boomer Esiason called out Aikman for being pro Cowboys. “You would have thought the Arizona Cardinals weren’t even in the building,” Esiason said. “The bias that was coming from him yesterday was stunning. I couldn’t believe some of the things he was saying.”

He particularly blasted him for propping up Dallas QB Tony Romo.

One Redskins fan from Greensboro had this to say online. “He is a forever a Cowboy, We are the Redskins. I would hate to think I had to commentate a Cowboys game. I would totally suck. Hate would prevail.”

Others say the play-by-play guy Joe Buck is even more anti-Redskin than Aikman and that Daryl Johnston, another former Cowboy who covered a lot of Redskins games in past years, is the worst of the three. I suspect a lot of announcers, even if they aren’t ex-Cowboys, don’t like the Redskins because of controversial owner Dan Synder.

I actually like Aikman as a person but he does seem to be rooting for the other team sometimes when calling Redskins games. I understand that Buck, Aikman and Pam Oliver are considered the top announcing crew and the Redskins have been in some big games against good opponents. Other than that, I’m not really sure why Fox insists on having ex-Cowboys doing Redskins games. I doubt very seriously that Cowboys fans would put up with Joe Theismann doing their games every week.

Former Panther helps Panthers finally win a game

Quarterback David Carr finally has helped the Panthers – three years after playing with them. Carr came in to relieve San Francisco’s Alex Smith, who was injured, and threw an interception late in the game with the score tied. The Carolina Panthers moved in close enough for John Kasay to kick a game-winning 37-yard field goal.

Carolina moves to 1-5 while San Francisco falls to 1-6.

Carr came in at the third quarter and threw a well underthrown pass on third down. He finished with a 58 quarterback rating going 5 of 13. When he was with the Panthers in 2007, he threw five interceptions and three touchdowns.

Richard Marshall intercepted the pass that set up the game-winning field goal by Kasay, who earlier hit a 53 yarder.

The Panthers, trailing 20-13 late in the game, tied the score when rookie David Gettis, who earlier dropped a pass in the end zone, made a diving TD reception with 1:53 left.

Panthers’ QB Matt Moore finished 28 of 41 for 308 yards and two touchdowns and an interception.

Things won’t be easy for the Panthers as they play only two teams with losing records the rest of the way, including the 3-4 St. Louis Rams next week.

While neither team is happy with its season, 49er fans seem to be particularly distressed as the 49ers were expected to be a contender for the playoffs.

As David Fucillo, a Bay Area contributor for SB Nation, wrote, “Well, just when I was wondering how the 49ers could find a new way to kick us in the junk, they do it. The 49ers dropped another nail-biter 23-20 to the Carolina Panthers thanks to an incredibly soft secondary and the loss of Alex Smith to a sprained shoulder. While I do think the 49ers probably win this game if Alex Smith does’t get hurt, I also think the team could have still won the game if the defense, and the secondary in particular, showed a little bit of aggression on those last couple drives.”

The Buffalo Bills, overtime losers to the Baltimore Ravens, are now the only winless team left in the NFL.

Miami drubs Carolina – Now, that’s more what we expected from depleted Heels

After four straight impressive wins, it appears the suspensions and injuries have finally caught up with the Tar Heels as Miami crushed North Carolina 33-10.

The Tar Heels actually had a 10-3 lead early and should have been up by more except for a fumble in the end zone. But then, on the heels of losing tight end Zack Pianalto for the season, the injuries started piling up. Five Tar Heels went down including Pianalto’s replacement Ryan Taylor.

Miami, which probably would have won the game regardless of the injuries, reeled off 30 straight points. Several big plays came through the air against the depleted Carolina secondary, which was playing three freshmen and another player, Da’Norris Searcy, who had been knocked woozy earlier.

With nine players having been dismissed, suspended or otherwise held out just in case, it was going to be a tough task at Miami without the four injuries last week and five during the game.

Some players who had previously only played on special teams got to see action for Carolina. The four defensive backs playing at the end of the game were the last four defensive backs on the team.

Despite leading questions, UNC coach Butch Davis didn’t sulk about the injuries. He praised Miami as a good football team and said the Tar Heels had a chance to get some points early and didn’t come through.

“The kids tried as hard as they can,” Davis said, finally alluding to the shorthandedness. “Like I tell them, you never know when your number is going to be called. A lot of kids had to play tonight and hopefully we’ll be better for it next week.”

Carolina has a homecoming game against William & Mary next Saturday before traveling back to Florida to play Florida State, a team that handled Miami easily a couple of weeks ago.

Hamilton wins ALCS MVP award as Rangers pop cork on… ginger ale

Raleigh’s Josh Hamilton, who has struggled with alcohol and drug abuse, was awarded the American League Championship Series MVP Award following his team’s 6-1 victory over the New York Yankees.

The win clinched a trip to the World Series. Instead of popping the cork on traditional champagne, Hamilton’s teammates sprayed ginger ale on each other out of respect for Hamilton and his issues with alcohol.

Hamilton hit .350 in the series while hitting four home runs and driving in seven runs. “First of all, all glory goes to God, Jesus Christ,” Hamilton said. “Secondly, i love my teammates. Any of these guys could have gotten this award… I don’t want to talk about myself – I want to talk about them.”

Hamilton said the Rangers are in this position because the players “don’t know how to fail” and there is great team chemistry. “The guys love each other and support each other,” he said.

Hamilton, whose voice was cracking as he was being interviewed about what he means to win the MVP after all his struggles, said in the final inning he was in the outfield tearing up, trying to hold it all together in case the ball was hit to him. “It means a lot with everything i’ve been through and what God has brought me through to this point with this group of guys,” he said. “I’m so excited and I feel blessed.”

He has 26 tattoos that he now tries to hide and which he got while drinking and doing drugs in Florida early in his professional career. “My first drink – my first drink ever – was at a strip club down there, with the tattoo guys,” Hamilton said a few years ago. “Pretty soon, I started using. First the powder. Then crack. I was 20. I wasn’t playing. I was hurt. My parents left and went back home. I was by myself for the first time.”

The whole world is with the popular Hamilton now and many are rooting for him and his Rangers team as they go to the World Series to play the winner of the Giants-Phillies series.

Carolina fans firmly behind Butch Davis, survey shows

NEWS RELEASE – A new poll of North Carolina voters describing themselves as UNC fans finds that football coach Butch Davis retains strong support from his fan base and that there is little sentiment in favor of replacing him.

Overall 41 percent of UNC fans approve of the job Davis is doing as coach to 20 percent who disapprove. This survey was conducted before the team won in Charlottesville for the first time in 29 years last weekend. Respondents were asked to describe their fandom of the team as ‘hardcore’ or ‘casual’ and among the most devoted fans Davis’ approval rises to 59 percent with only 21 percent unhappy with his performance.

There’s been a lot of discussion recently about Davis’ future at North Carolina given all of the team’s issues with the NCAA but only 14 percent of the Tar Heel fan base thinks he should be fired to 57 percent who think he should continue on in his position. That sentiment is even stronger among those who identified themselves as ‘hardcore’ fans. Only 9 percent of them supported replacing Davis while 68 percent said he should remain as coach.

“For everything that’s happened in the UNC football program over the last three months Butch Davis remains extremely popular with Tar Heel fans,” said Tom Jensen, Director of Public Policy Polling. “That seems to reflect a sentiment that the team’s off field troubles are not Davis’ fault, as well as appreciation for the strides the team has made on the field since Davis became the coach.”

The poll had another interesting finding. While 46 percent of voters statewide describe themselves as Democrats to 37 percent who are Republicans, those identifying as Carolina fans break down as 53 percent Democrats and 32 percent Republicans. And those describing themselves as ‘hardcore’ UNC fans are 59 percent Democrats and 29 percent Republicans. Those data points indicate the general perceptions about the political disposition of UNC people may be correct.

PPP surveyed 597 likely North Carolina voters from Oct. 15-17 and 159 of those respondents identified themselves as UNC fans. The margin of error on that subgroup is +/-7.8 percent. Other factors, such as refusal to be interviewed and weighting, may introduce additional error that is more difficult to quantify.

Ten area high school football games to consider attending, with predictions

For the second time in as many weeks, my record of predicting area high school football games was a perfect 10-0, making the season total now 72-18, which is 80 percent accuracy. Here are 10 football games that are within driving distance in the Triangle area this Friday night. After today’s rain, Friday night’s weather is nice with virtually no chance at rain. Most games are at 7:30 p.m. You might want to check with local officials as some games start at 7. In bold below are the predicted winners.

Apex at Green Hope

Fuquay-Varina at Athens Drive

Garner at Southeast Raleigh

Millbrook at Leesville Road

Panther Creek at Middle Creek

Sanderson at Wake Forest-Rolesville

Wakefield at Enloe

Southern Durham at East Chapel Hill

J.F. Webb at Chapel Hill

North Raleigh Christian at Wake Christian

Check the scores in our Sports Roundup on the left navigation bar.

O’Brien gives Pack players a few days off before preparing for FSU

After losing in overtime at rival East Carolina, and with no game this weekend, NC State coach Tom O’Brien figured his players needed a little time off.

“We will get on the football field for the tomorrow for the first time since saturday,” O’Brien said Wednesday. “I gave the fellas a few days off. They’re tired and we need to try to get back both mentally and physically.”

The Wolfpack hosts Florida State Thursday, Oct. 28 in a primetime ESPN game that could put the season back on track or continue to bring the Pack down to earth.

State, 5-2, got off to a 4-0 start before losing heartbreakers to Virginia Tech at home and ECU on the road.

“I think we are a much more competitive football team than we’ve been the past three years,” O’Brien said. “That’s due a lot to the young kids growing up and getting much more experience. But the biggest thing is we haven’t suffered the devastating injuries we have the last two years.”

He said not only is the team healthier overall but deeper since the players who had to step in over the last couple of years now have more experience.

Florida State is 6-1 and atop the Atlantic Division with a 4-0 mark. The winner of this game would be the favorite to take the division.

“We have a huge challenge but thank God we have some time to rest,” O’Brien said. “Hopefully we can regroup and have a great night next Thursday night.”

ACC basketball preseason predictions before writers’ official picks today

Our Dane Huffman will be providing live updates today from Operation ACC Basketball in Charlotte and will be voting with the other ACC basketball writers on the following categories. Prior to the official voting by the sportswriters in attendance, I thought I’d weigh in on preseason honors.

Predicted Order
Duke
Virginia Tech
UNC
NC State
Florida State
Maryland
Clemson
Miami
Boston College
Georgia Tech
Virginia
Wake Forest

First team All-ACC
Kyle Singler, Duke
Nolan Smith, Duke
Malcolm Delaney Va. Tech
Tracy Smith, NC State
Harrison Barnes, UNC

Second team All-ACC
Dorenzo Hudson, Va. Tech
John Henson, UNC
Chris Singleton, Florida State
Kyrie Irving, Duke
Jordan Williams, Maryland

Third team All-ACC
Jeff Allen, Va. Tech
Seth Curry, Duke
Tyler Zeller, UNC
Demontez Stitt, Clemson
Durand Scott, Miami

All-Freshman team
Harrison Barnes, UNC
CJ Leslie, NC State
Ryan Harrow, NC State
Kyrie Irving, Duke
Reggie Bullock, UNC

All-ACC Defensive team
Chris Singleton, Florida State
Iman Shumpert, Ga. Tech
Jordan Williams, Maryland
John Henson, UNC
Soloman Alabi, Florida State

Cutcliffe says team has confidence in Renfree, even after five picks

At the beginning of the season, Duke fans dreamed that Sean Renfree would live up to his potential as quarterback and sneak the Blue Devils into a bowl game. He hasn’t, they won’t.

Renfree even threw five interceptions last week against Miami before being lifted for freshman Brandon Connette, who moved the ball better. But Duke coach David Cutcliffe says he will start Renfree and that he and the team have confidence in him.

“He understands the responsibility, and out squad has confidence in him,” Cutcliffe said. “I can’t make that happen, nor can he. Ultimately what it comes down to is performance on game day. He can’t fix this in one day, but rather one play at a time.”

Those plays this week come against heavily favored Virginia Tech.

“The quarterback has had a little bit of a problem here lately, but I think he’s got a tremendous upside,” VT coach Frank Beamer said.

He pointed out that Duke averages about 400 yards per game, of which 278 are passing yards, and that Renfree completes 57 percent of his passes. And, to be fair, several of the interceptions were tipped passes.

Cutcliffe said that the team is depending on Renfree to be prepared mentally and physically. “He is a big boy and he is taking that challenge on. He is not running away from it,” he said.

Too bad the first opportunity to atone for those five interceptions comes at Virginia Tech.

Panthers’ Clausen benched in favor of Moore – Ok, whatever

Carolina Panthers coach John Fox released a statement today saying that Matt Moore will return to replace Danny Clausen as quarterback.

This “quarterback controversy” isn’t exactly Montana vs. Young or Jurgensen vs. Kilmer. Whatever Fox’ gut tells him to do is ok I guess. Whomever practices better probably should start. But the franchise needs to decide if Clausen is the future or Moore is the future.

“We have struggled on offense since the beginning of the season and sometimes it helps to step back and watch and Matt has had a chance to do that,” Fox said today.

Somehow I think the Panthers intended to stick with Clausen when he took over, not merely give Moore a break to observe. Perhaps both quarterbacks have a future in the NFL but it doesn’t appear that this season will be good for either. It probably doesn’t matter which guy is quarterbacking as far as wins but it might as far as developing the future.

The Panthers, who play 1-5 San Francisco Sunday, stand at 0-5 and are one of two teams who are winless – the Bills are the other.

NFL Note: At FedEx Field Sunday night, about 50 Washington Redskins alumni were introduced including former Duke and Wilmington product Sonny Jurgensen. When the new HD television screen showed Jurgensen, his name was misspelled as “Jurgenson.” You’d think that a five-time all-pro who threw for more than 32,000 yards and was proclaimed by legendary coach Vince Lombardi as the best quarterback he’d ever seen, could have his name spelled correctly by his own team.